Skip to content


BART Independent Police Auditor job posting

BART has just posted a job listing for Executive Staff Assistant, Independent Police Auditor. The BART Police obviously are generating a lot of demand for independent audits, having killed at least two people recently.

Despite changing chiefs (following last year’s killing) the department is now facing the same heavy criticism from the public. They are accused of taking too long to explain events and details from this past July 3rd, when an officer shot and killed a man 25 seconds after confronting him.

One of the complaints I see is that a 250-member police force has been unapproachable and even refused witness testimony.

Some of the cops began asking if anyone had seen the shooting, she said.

Hollero said she told one police officer that she had, but she said it didn’t seem like the officer was interested in following up. She left the station without giving an interview to police.

In the days since, Hollero called the San Francisco Police Department, which is investigating the shooting, to report what she saw. She reached an officer Wednesday morning; when she identified herself as a witness to the shooting on Sunday, she said the officer asked, “What shooting are you referring to?”

When she told him, he answered that “this is sounding like a BART issue” and said she should call the BART tip line — but he didn’t have the number. Hollero said that she then called BART [tip line: 510-464-7040], but only got an answering machine.

The auditor role appears designed to help with that and other important functions for running investigations such as processing and releasing information to the public more quickly.

5. Screens incoming calls, responds to questions and complaints from the general public or from departments; provides information based on knowledge of existing policies, procedures, programs, or services; reviews and investigates problems, and recommends appropriate action or referral; prepares summary reports as required.

6. Obtains essential information from complainants, witnesses, and others, including over the phone, in-person, or through written or electric correspondence, necessary for the Office of the Independent Police Auditor to initiate an investigation.

7. Receives visitors to the Office of the Independent Police Auditor, including members of the public and individuals from other BART departments, and determines how to address their requests, inquiries, etc.

8. Independently composes, compiles and prepares correspondence, reports and documents; reviews finished materials for completeness, accuracy and compliance with District policies and procedures.

I’ll let you draw your own conclusions from the released surveillance video.

Your browser is not able to display this multimedia content.

What jumps out to me is the police draw and fire bullets yet the video indicates other passengers are not far away and that they sense no serious/station threat. They leave the area calmly without pause to assess the danger, which could explain why there have been no amateur videos or photos released.

The official police report says the victim raised a large knife above his head but he is too far away to be seen in the video.

The victim also is said to have broken a glass bottle near the more experienced officer, who then slipped and fell on the liquid. The knife may have been threatening but the sound/visual of a bottle being broken and an officer slipping and falling down sounds far more likely to have been what spooked the less experienced officer into firing his gun. Audio would certainly help…

The only audio so far is a recording of the officer with only 18 months experience calmly reporting that he (officer #41) has just fired shots at a man with a knife and needs a code 3 ambulance (emergency response).

Interesting to note the similarities in the Oscar Grant and Charles Hill investigations. Both were holidays (New Years 2009 and 4th of July 2011), both were late night reports of drunk and disorderly conduct, and both involved officers with less than two years experience firing bullets instead of their taser (although it’s not clear yet whether the officer firing bullets in the latest case was the one carrying a taser)

Posted in Security.


0 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.