Israel’s Unit 8200 Veterans’ Firm Found Inside Tim Hortons App

Tim Hortons settled its last location-tracking case with a free hot drink and a baked good. Seriously. Court documents valued them at $6.19 and $2.39. A Quebec court approved the deal in September 2022, and four years later the same app has been caught collecting location-revealing data through an outside vendor AGAIN.

Who wants a hot drink and baked good?

University of Calgary computer scientist Joel Reardon and his team looked at the app’s network traffic. The result went into a CBC Marketplace story. The app begins sending data to an outside company the moment it opens. The data includes device identifiers, camera specifications, the list of sensors, the names of ringtones and alarms, and the names of nearby wi-fi routers. Those wi-fi identifiers track where a phone is. Reardon called the collection “beyond the pale“. He told Al Jazeera that it happens before the user consents, which is particularly notable. He also pointed out effective fraud prevention doesn’t need this.

CBC withheld the name of the company receiving the data. Why? I’m not sure. They said responsibility lies with the app’s developer. Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East asked Reardon and published the name so we don’t have to guess: Forter. Al Jazeera reports that it confirmed the Forter connection independently.

Tim Hortons told CBC it was a fraud prevention situation, where account and payment protection and stays out of marketing. It said the company and its vendor can not sell the data.

Ok, but the last case had the same sounding issues. In June 2022 the federal privacy commissioner and the commissioners of Quebec, Alberta and British Columbia found that the app broke Canadian privacy law. Starting in May 2019 it recorded users’ locations “every few minutes of every day”, including while the app was closed. It inferred where users lived and worked, and it logged their visits to competitors to Tim Hortons. Targeted advertising was the stated purpose, but that’s not what customers ended up with.

The vendor in that case was Radar, a US-based provider under contract to RBI US Services LLC. That’s an American affiliate of Tim Hortons’ parent company Restaurant Brands International. The contract allowed Radar to use the data for its own purposes in aggregated or de-identified form, which is why the regulators found that it failed to protect users. They also found Tim Hortons had skipped privacy assessments at the key decision points. So that is why Tim Hortons agreed to build a privacy management program and to assess privacy impact before launching new app practices. In June 2023 the federal commissioner’s office announced it was “satisfied that the company has met its commitments”.

That is the backstory for Forter either getting approved, or somehow else getting through. Let’s look at the diffs:

Radar, 2019 to 2020 Forter, 2026
US-based, hired through RBI US Services LLC New York headquarters, founded in Tel Aviv
GPS location every few minutes, app open or closed Device fingerprint and nearby wi-fi names at launch
Stated purpose: targeted advertising Stated purpose: fraud prevention
Exposed by a Financial Post reporter Exposed by CBC and University of Calgary tests
Four regulators found the law broken. Users received a drink and a pastry. Regulators have yet to act. CJPME has asked the federal commissioner to investigate.

The brand is Canadian. The data handling keeps turning out American. Radar is a US company hired through a US entity. While Forter was founded in Tel Aviv by ex-military intelligence (all three founders came out of the infamous Israeli unit 8200), it now lists entities in Tel Aviv, New York, London and Singapore. It certifies itself to the US Commerce Department as Forter, Inc. That makes it a US company under US jurisdiction, and the US Justice Department says such a company can be required to hand over data it controls, wherever that data is stored.

For European customers Forter opened a data centre in Ireland and named the GDPR as the reason. The GDPR carries fines. Compare that to Canada’s limp federal commissioner who issues only findings and recommendations. The 2022 case closed with no penalties.

That seems like a point worth making more loudly these days, as Canada does ban apps on the basis of jurisdiction. In October 2023 the federal government removed WeChat and Kaspersky from government phones, eight months after it removed TikTok. The chief information officer judged that the two posed “an unacceptable level of risk to privacy and security”. The government acted on assessed risk, without even any evidence of compromised information.

They could hold the same line on apps that put Canadian data within reach of Trump and Netanyahu.

The evidence in the Tim Hortons case is stronger than you might think. Four Canadian regulators already have a finding on file that Tim Hortons broke the law with a US vendor embedded in its app. The class-action remedy was calculated at $8.58 per user affected. CBC’s tests now show a second US-registered vendor, founded by Israeli military intelligence veterans, collecting from the same app. Sounds like it’s about time for Canadians to apply their own standard and ban American apps.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.